Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

Rated 8.1 in 174 reviews. 102 rooms.


Rich in history, yet recently refreshed for a new era of guests, the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina (MYC) is an award-winning Hamptons hotel ideal for weekend getaways, family vacations and milestone events. We are beautifully located on a private waterfront in the East Hampton hamlet of Montauk, which is on the South Fork of Long Island. Graced by our replica of the historic Montauk Lighthouse, MYC offers an inviting blend of bygone elegance and modern comfort for travelers visiting by air, land or sea.
At the Montauk Yacht Club, we provide a level of privacy which is unique among Montauk hotels and offers vacationers a true escape from the pressures of daily life. The resort’s 106 guest rooms, villas and suites feature nautical-inspired décor and private balconies or terraces that overlook the waterfront or our tranquil courtyard.

Situated on Star Island in Lake Montauk, this Long Island resort and spa features a private beach, 3 swimming pools, and boat rentals. Rooms include a private wooden balcony.

The accommodations at Gurney's Star Island are nautical-themed with whitewashed walls and nautical artwork. They are equipped with a flat-screen TV, free WiFi, and iPod docking station. A coffee maker and refrigerator are also provided.

This resort offers 3 on-site dining options, including Showfish, The Pool Club and Il Forno.

Spa services are offered at this Montauk resort. Volleyball courts, lighted tennis courts, and horseshoe pits are located on the property. Concierge services are available.

Rita’s Horse Stables and the Montauk Downs Golf Course are 5 minutes from Gurney’s Star Island. The Montauk Point Lighthouse and Museum is 10 minutes from the resort.

Spa Facilities

  • Indoor pool (all year)
  • Fitness
  • Fitness classes
  • Swimming pool
  • Beach
  • Fitness centre
  • Indoor pool
  • Outdoor pool
  • Private beach area
  • Outdoor pool (seasonal)

Available Rooms

2 guests




Recommended Nearby

A guide to great places near Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina

  1. Barracuda Bar

    15 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd

  2. My Mate Charters

    25 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd Slip 603

  3. Coast Kitchen

    Wonderful service. Get the scallops

    38 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd

  4. Hurricane Alley

    Dwayne is changing the cocktail game here. Definitely a must visit.

    46 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd

  5. Beach at Montauk Yacht Club

    Beautiful, quiet in the off season.

    51 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd

  6. Montauk Yacht Club Gym

    62 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd

  7. Montauk Yacht Club

    if you actually want to feel like you're on vacation, get a water view room.

    67 m from hotel
    32 Star Island Rd

  8. Westlake Fish House

    The sushi bar here is the best in Montauk. Dockside, tucked away from the busy village center, new beers on tap weekly, and live music on the weekends. THIS is Montauk.

    477 m from hotel
    352 W Lake Dr

  9. The Hideaway

    Get the fish tacos

    0.6 km from hotel
    364 W Lake Dr

  10. Swallow East Restaurant

    Blackened shrimp tacos are delicious. Go on a Tuesday night in summer when Kathleen Fee sings out on the back porch.

    0.7 km from hotel
    474 West Lake Drive

  11. Ben & Jerry's

    Very nice service, let me take a taste and recommended a great Carmel flavor!!

    0.8 km from hotel
    478 West Lake Drive Extension

  12. Crow's Nest

    Great squash blossoms, and have an après dinner at the fire pit!

    2.9 km from hotel
    4 Old West Lake Dr